VCL-Transfer
Design Patterns for VCL arrangements by the Chair of Business Informatics, especially Information Management at the TU Dresden.
Expertise as a criterion
Patterns >> Management of Roles >> Expertise as a criterion
Problem | The participants’ skills and experience can differ considerably. This influences how they work with the tasks. Different expertise and different expertise combinations within a group will lead to different group results. |
---|---|
Framework | Differences in existing knowledge and skills of the participants (e.g. students from different programmes, on different study level, with or without working experience); a task that is meant to make different solutions possible and leaves it to the participants to create their own results; |
Solution |
The participants should be encouraged to actively use the experience and skills they have. The organisers are free to decide to make the participants’ previous experience one of the criteria of the team assignment. As personal experience of the participants is in many cases closely connected to their institutional affiliation (participants from one institution are often students from the same programme, they have taken similar courses and are on a similar level), it is often taken into account indirectly. Making it an explicit criterion of team assignment can be done for following reasons:
In the above mentioned two cases, expertise needs to be an explicit criterion of the group assignment. Especially in the letter case (need for multidisciplinary methods), it is advisable to take expertise into account also in the role design by connecting expertise to specific roles. In order to take participants’ expertise into account, it has to be known. In some cases, it is reasonable to make assumptions, e.g. based on the study programme of the participants. Special expertise (such as working experience, special interests) needs to be described by the participants themselves. If the expertise is connected to the role concept, such descriptions can be a part of a role application. |
Links |